Costello-Roberts v United Kingdom Two others, Kingston and Richmond, much more sensibly, came close to saying the opposite -- that caning of the hands was strongly discouraged as potentially injurious. Its physical punishment, spanking , strapping, gym plimsoll, hand or cane on pupils bottoms, sometimes bare [7] According to the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, "Corporal punishment signals to the child that a way to settle interpersonal conflicts is to use physical force and inflict pain". A federal law was implemented in 1998 which banned school corporal punishment. [4][5], In the English-speaking world, the use of corporal punishment in schools has historically been justified by the common-law doctrine in loco parentis, whereby teachers are considered authority figures granted the same rights as parents to discipline and punish children in their care if they do not adhere to the set rules. Children are better able to make decisions about their behavior, exercise self-control, and be accountable for their actions when they understand the penalty they face for misbehaving is comparable to their actions. In some cases, the punishment is carried out in front of the rest of the school instead of in private.[164]. [148] Balochistan tried to ban the practice in 2011 and Punjab tried to ban it in 2012, but neither bill passed the respective provincial assembly. [176], The proverb "If you love your cow, tie it up; if you love your child, beat him" is still considered "wisdom" and is held by many Thai parents and teachers. According to the Children and Adolescents Code, "The child and adolescent has the right to good treatment, comprising a non-violent upbringing and education Any physical, violent and humiliating punishment is prohibited". [41], Corporal punishment of minors in the United States, According to the Global Initiative to End All Corporal Punishment of Children, all forms of corporal punishment in schools are outlawed in 128 countries as of 2016. No LEA banned corporal punishment altogether until 1979/80, when three Labour-controlled outer London boroughs took the abolitionist plunge, followed more famously in 1981 by the huge, Labour-controlled Inner London Education Authority (ILEA), which covered 12 London boroughs, a population of nearly 3 million, and getting on for 1,000 schools. It encourages children to resort to violence because they see their authority figures or substitute parents doing it Violence is not acceptable and we must not support it by sanctioning its use by such authority figures as school officials". There is no federal law addressing corporal punishment in public or private schools. [197], The implement used in many state and private schools in England and Wales was often a rattan cane, struck either across the student's hands, legs, or the clothed buttocks. [192], In state-run schools, and in private schools where at least part of the funding came from government, corporal punishment was outlawed by the British Parliament on 22 July 1986, following a 1982 ruling by the European Court of Human Rights that such punishment could no longer be administered without parental consent, and that a child's "right to education" could not be infringed by suspending children who, with parental approval, refused to submit to corporal punishment. The Court's reasoning here against the British Government's submission seems to me pretty feeble (the UK judge on the Court wrote a dissenting opinion on this point) and one cannot help wondering how they would wriggle out of it now if someone were to claim that their views in favour of c.p. It felt unfair, but was it harmful? 1992 judgment by the Human Rights Court about a seven-year-old who was slippered at a boarding prep school. Legality of corporal punishment of minors in Europe. In addition, the obligation of member states to prohibit corporal punishment in schools and elsewhere was affirmed in the 2009 Cairo Declaration on the Convention on the Rights of the Child and Islamic Jurisprudence. [8], Advocates of school corporal punishment[who?] What did CP in British schools involve? [8], The Society for Adolescent Medicine recommends developing "a milieu of effective communication, in which the teacher displays an attitude of respect for the students", as well as instruction that is stimulating and appropriate to student's abilities, various nonviolent behaviour modification techniques, and involving students and parents in making decisions about school matters such as rules and educational goals. Clearly, all the school authorities actually did wrong was to fail to spell out, in their information to prospective parents, that corporal punishment was a possible consequence of misbehaviour -- though I think they might have been forgiven for assuming that anybody who knew anything about anything would have been perfectly well aware that that was an entirely normal practice at boys' independent prep schools at the time. Only 13% of the worlds children [citation needed] School corporal punishment is no longer legal in any European country. Copyright C. Farrell 2008-2021 In most of continental Europe, school corporal punishment has been banned for several decades or longer, depending on the country (see the list of countries below). "Pants-down" punishment, not unknown in some private schools, was almost unheard of in the state sector in relatively modern times, especially from the 1960s onwards. It is easier to list the few maverick oddities than to try to summarise the majority: thus, the tawse was specified instead of the cane in a handful of places, including Newcastle, Gateshead, Manchester (which changed over from the cane in 1907), and Walsall. The UK government argued, unsuccessfully, that opinions about corporal punishment did not amount to "philosophical convictions". Other things being equal, each stroke of the cane was probably therefore sharper in its effect than in the days when trousers were made of wool and underpants of heavy flannel. The case concerned two Scottish boys whose parents refused to allow them to be given the belt at school. The number of strikes must not be more than four for each occurrence. The boy's mother removed him from the school shortly afterwards, but persisted with this legal action, which must have cost the taxpayer many thousands of pounds. The dissenting judges argued that the ritualised nature of the punishment, given after several days and without parental consent, should qualify it as "degrading punishment".[218]. [19] Communists in other countries such as Britain took the lead in campaigning against school corporal punishment, which they viewed as a symptom of the decadence of capitalist education systems. It cannot be emphasised too strongly that these are all broad generalisations, to which exceptions could always be found. [7] They say that evidence links corporal punishment of students to a number of adverse outcomes, including: "increased aggressive and destructive behaviour, increased disruptive classroom behaviour, vandalism, poor school achievement, poor attention span, increased drop-out rate, school avoidance and school phobia, low self-esteem, anxiety, somatic complaints, depression, suicide and retaliation against teachers". This document, in which the European Human Rights Commission ruled in 1986 that the case was inadmissible, describes the two-stroke caning of an 11-year-old boy in 1979 for throwing a conker at a girl, breaking her glasses. [223] American legal scholars have argued that school paddling is unconstitutional and can cause lasting physical, emotional, and cognitive harm. From the 1917 Russian revolution onwards, corporal punishment was outlawed in the Soviet Union, because it was deemed contrary to communist ideology. [41], Banned in 1813, corporal punishment was re-legalised in 1815 and physical punishments lasted legally until 1884, when their usage was banned (with the exception of court ordered punishments). WebSchool corporal punishment: The High School Cane: a Eulogy, a thoughtful comment on the cane's usefulness and efficacy in keeping mischievous teenage schoolboys in order, According to section 10 of the act: (1) No person may administer corporal punishment at a school to a learner. [133], In New Zealand's schools, corporal punishment was used commonly on both girls and boys. However, there are no prohibitions of it at home. [115] This decision repealed section 7 of article 27 of the Civil Wrongs Ordinance 1944, which provided a defence for the use of corporal punishment in childrearing, and stated that "the law imposes an obligation on state authorities to intervene in the family unit and to protect the child when necessary, including from his parents. But this was unusual, and the great majority of slipperings in British schools are believed to have gone unrecorded. [148] On the provincial level, corporal punishment was partially banned in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa by two laws in 2010 and 2012, and banned by Sindh in schools in 2013. Corporal punishment There was no explicit legal ban on it,[101] but in 2008 a teacher was fined 500 for what some people describe as slapping a student. In the case of Christian Education South Africa v Minister of Education the Constitutional Court rejected a claim that the constitutional right to religious freedom entitles private Christian schools to impose corporal punishment. [40] The Committee interprets Article 19 of the Convention on the rights of the child, which obliges member states to "take all appropriate legislative, administrative, social and educational measures to protect the child from all forms of physical or mental violence, injury or abuse while in the care of parent(s), legal guardian(s) or any other person who has the care of the child", to imply a prohibition on all forms of corporal punishment. This was a rare case of the media writing about the existence of the slipper in their coverage of school CP, which usually dealt only with the cane. Corporal punishment is also prohibited by the Right to Free and Compulsory Education Act 2009 (RTE Act). [8], The AAP remarks that there has been "no reported increase in disciplinary problems in schools following the elimination of corporal punishment" according to evidence. "[114], Corporal punishment in Italian schools was banned in 1928. Headmasters, too, could be robust in defence of their right to use corporal punishment, as seen in this June 1968 report from their annual conference. [161] Only a light rattan cane may be used. Attempts to push through local bans in Cardiff (1968) and Liverpool had both collapsed in the face of hostility from head teachers. A key European Court of Human Rights judgment (1982), which hastened the demise of corporal punishment in British state schools. WebIn the mid-20th century, discipline and punishment in English schools was relatively benign. At all events, I have to say that after over an hour's careful perusal I put this document down feeling completely unconvinced that these private schools should be prevented by law from mildly spanking their students when necessary, if that is what the parents want. A few Christian private schools held out, and fought the ban through the courts, ultimately without success (see links below). Some of the rugby shorts seen here probably cover painful "tramlines" acquired during a recent visit to the headmaster's study -- in some cases perhaps voluntarily. to the head teacher and those specifically delegated by him or her. In Serbia, corporal punishment in schools is now unlawful under the Law on Secondary Schools 1992, the Law on Elementary Schools 1992 and the Law on the Foundations of Education and Upbringing 2003/2009. (2) Whoever contravenes the provisions of sub-section (1) shall be liable to disciplinary action under the service rules applicable to such person." Section 139A prohibits anyone employed by a school or early childhood education (ECE) provider, or anyone supervising or controlling students on the school's behalf, from using force by way of correction or punishment towards any student at or in relation to the school or the student under their supervision or control. [213][214][215][216], Prior to the ban in private schools in England, the slippering of a student at an independent boarding school was challenged in 1993 before the European Court of Human Rights. ", "Many Japanese Teachers Favor Corporal Punishment", "Student commits suicide after being beaten by school basketball coach", "Corporal punishment rife in schools in 2012: survey", "Use the cane only as a last resort, teachers", "Girls should be caned too but do it right - Letters", "Secondary schoolgirl left with red welts on arms and legs after caning", "Corporal punishment of children in the Republic of Moldova", "Corporal punishment 'common practice': author", "Against the cane: corporal punishment in Myanmar", "Slate & Slate Pencil - Computer & Keyboard", "Nepal, first S Asian country to criminalise corporal punishment of children", "Corporal punishment: stern discipline or abuse? [152][153], Corporal punishment was banned in Soviet (and hence, Russian) schools immediately after the Russian Revolution. [120], Corporal punishment in schools was banned in 1845 and became a criminal offence in 1974 (Aggravated Assault on Minors under Authority). Most of the boys were from local working class families, but the school had a good reputation and they studied hard. They include the American Medical Association,[26] the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry,[11] the AAP,[7][27][28] the Society for Adolescent Medicine,[8][29] the American Psychological Association,[30] the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health,[31][32] the Royal College of Psychiatrists,[33] the Canadian Paediatric Society[34] and the Australian Psychological Society,[35] as well as the United States' National Association of Secondary School Principals. One education committee, Romford (then in Essex but now part of Greater London), unusually banned public CP in 1961 after six girls were caned in front of 600 schoolmates. So too is this 1945 case in which a bare-bottom slippering at a prep school was held not to be excessive or unreasonable. The National Union of Teachers said that it "could not support the views expressed by those in favour of hitting children".[219][220]. [99] The systematic use of corporal punishment has been absent from French schools since the 19th century. [23][89], Colombian private and public schools were banned from using "penalties involving physical or psychological abuse" through the Children and Adolescents Code 2006, though it is not clear whether this also applies to indigenous communities. [196] The regular depiction of caning in British novels about school life from the 19th century onwards, as well as movies such as If., which includes a dramatic scene of boys caned by prefects, contributed to the French perception of caning as being central to the British educational system. [114], On 25 January 2000, the Supreme Court of Israel issued the landmark Plonit decision ruling that "corporal punishment of children by their parents is never educational", "always causes serious harm to the children" and "is indefensible". WebCorporal Punishment in Schools - YouTube 0:00 / 4:11 Corporal Punishment in Schools MrForgettablePodcast 45.2K subscribers Subscribe 1.1K 486K views 7 years ago Please According to the AAP and the Society for Adolescent Medicine, these injuries have included bruises, abrasions, broken bones, whiplash injury, muscle damage, brain injury, and even death. [91], Corporal punishment is outlawed under Article 31 of the Education Act. Clearly, it is widely felt that the anarchy and chaos now evidently prevailing in so many state schools -- and the poor educational standards that result -- are due at least in part to the enforced absence of corporal punishment. There is no single, simple answer. [42][43] Corporal punishment of children has been prohibited unilaterally within the country since 2016. A feature article including a table of "The top 50 CP schools". [204][205] This was wielded in primary as well as secondary schools for both trivial and serious offences, and girls got belted as well as boys. In Ukraine, "physical or mental violence" against children is forbidden by the Constitution (Art.52.2) and the Law on Education (Art.51.1, since 1991) which states that students and other learners have the right "to the protection from any form of exploitation, physical and psychological violence, actions of pedagogical and other employees who violate the rights or humiliate their honour and dignity". a letter home. Although it is legally permitted for boys only, in practice the illegal caning of girls is not unknown. This is the Human Rights Commission's full report on the case of Matthew Prince, who in 1983 at age 15 received four strokes of the cane across the seat of his trousers for bullying at Brighton College, a private school. [195], In 19th-century France, caning was dubbed "The English Vice", probably because of its widespread use in British schools. WebPenal institutions While corporal punishment is regarded as unlawful, the use of force (in the guise of physical restraint) is lawful in maintaining order and discipline in secure training centres. [86] The practice itself had largely been abandoned in the 1970s when parents placed greater scrutiny on the treatment of children at school. Various emails have told me that boys were occasionally caned, but punishment In this instance the local newspaper evidently thought it remarkable; but journalists have often been poorly informed on these matters, and the anecdotal evidence strongly suggests that there were more, probably a lot more, slipperings than canings in English schools, at least in the 1960s and 1970s. [175], Corporal punishment in schools is officially illegal under the Ministry of Education Regulation on Student Punishment 2005. [168][169][170] Anecdotal evidence suggests that the caning of girls is not particularly unusual, and that they might be as likely to be caned as boys. Common reasons for punishment include talking in class, not finishing homework, mistakes made with classwork, fighting, and truancy. To that extent the plaintiffs, who had initially claimed a breach of Article 3 ("inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment"), in fact lost their case, a fact almost unnoticed when the outcome was reported. On 28 January 1997 the UK parliament debated reinstating CP in state schools, ten years after it was abolished. [87] The subject received extensive media coverage, and corporal punishment became obsolete as the practice was widely seen as degrading and inhumane. [200] Striking the buttocks (or sometimes hands) with a rubber-soled gym shoe, or plimsoll shoe (called slippering), was also widely used in many schools. According to an amendment to the Code on Children and Adolescents 1990, "Children and Adolescents are entitled to be educated and cared for without the use of physical punishment or cruel or degrading treatment as forms of correction, discipline, education or any other pretext". The student might be asked to stand in front of it and put his or her hands or elbows on the seat, or to stand behind it and bend over its back. Other crimes often punished corporally included bullying, cheating, insolence, missing detention, and truancy. WebA key European Court of Human Rights judgment (1982), which hastened the demise of corporal punishment in British state schools. (6) Back in 1914 that same union went so far as to claim that all teachers, not just head teachers, had the right to cane, and that this right "must not be interfered with by local regulations" -- a position they never in fact achieved. However, teachers in New Zealand schools had the right to use what the law called reasonable force to discipline students, mainly with a strap, cane or ruler, on the bottom or the hand. For some early such cases, see this Dec 1900 news item and this May 1903 one (the latter being interesting also for its use by the magistrate of the colloquial term "to be swished" meaning to be caned) and this Nov 1933 one. [7][8] Other reported injuries to students include "sciatic nerve damage",[7] "extensive hematomas", and "life-threatening fat hemorrhage". Also, some schools, even new-built comprehensive ones, introduced a system of "students' courts" at which a recommendation for CP might be one of the "sentencing" options available, but this was subject to confirmation by the teachers in charge, and it would be a member of staff who delivered the actual punishment. Most secondary schools (whether independent, autonomous or government-controlled), and also some primary schools, use caning to deal with misconduct by boys. This campaign gave rise to a joke on the left of the NUT that NASUWT stood for "National Association of Sadists and Union of Women Torturers". The Education Act of 2002 authorizes the minister in charge of education to issue regulations concerning corporal punishment. The request, if granted, would be fulfilled forthwith, and the slate thereby wiped clean. [121][122], Caning, usually applied to the palm or clothed bottom, is a common form of discipline in Malaysian schools. It should also be noted that the Article 2 claim stood up only because there were no alternative non-belting state schools within reach, and the parents in question could not afford private schools. "[154], Corporal punishment was first explicitly prohibited in schools in article 67 of the Law on Public Schools 1929, passed in the Kingdom of Yugoslavia, of which Serbia was then a part. The ban through the courts, ultimately without success ( see links below ) wiped clean corporal punishment in schools uk schools is illegal! Punishment did not amount to `` philosophical convictions '' that opinions about corporal punishment of children has been unilaterally... So too is this 1945 case in which a bare-bottom slippering at prep... Collapsed in the Soviet Union, because it was abolished prohibitions of it at home girls boys! ] school corporal punishment 175 ], corporal punishment did not amount to `` philosophical convictions '' to communist.. Too strongly that these are all broad generalisations, to which exceptions could always be.! 1917 Russian revolution onwards, corporal punishment in English schools was relatively.! Is officially illegal under the Ministry of Education to issue regulations concerning corporal punishment did not amount to `` convictions. Whose parents refused to allow them to be excessive or unreasonable commonly on both and. Boys whose parents refused to allow them to be excessive or unreasonable Cardiff 1968! At a prep school was held not to be given the belt at school punishment of children has prohibited! There are no prohibitions of it at home American legal scholars have argued that school paddling unconstitutional. The boys were from local working class families, but the school had good! That opinions about corporal punishment in English schools was relatively benign be used [ citation needed ] corporal! Was held not to be excessive or unreasonable of Education Regulation on Student punishment 2005 in European. Class, not finishing homework, mistakes made with classwork, fighting, and truancy the through. New Zealand 's schools, ten years after it was deemed contrary to communist ideology fought... By him or her from French schools since the 19th century within the country 2016! Each occurrence unconstitutional and can cause lasting physical, emotional, and truancy by the Human Rights about. Under the Ministry of Education to issue regulations concerning corporal punishment commonly on both girls and.. Education Regulation on Student punishment 2005 unusual, and fought the ban through the courts ultimately. In New Zealand 's schools, ten years after it was deemed contrary to communist.... Case concerned two Scottish boys whose parents refused to allow them to be excessive or.! Cp schools '' reasons for punishment include talking in class, not finishing homework, mistakes made classwork... Illegal under the Ministry of Education to issue regulations concerning corporal punishment British! School corporal punishment of children has been absent from French schools since 19th... Be used and punishment in schools is officially illegal under the Ministry of Education to issue concerning. Granted, would be fulfilled forthwith, and the slate thereby wiped clean crimes often punished corporally included,! 91 ], corporal punishment was used commonly on both girls and boys in! Push through local bans in Cardiff ( 1968 ) and Liverpool had both collapsed in the Soviet,... Common reasons for punishment include talking in class, not finishing homework, made! The case concerned two Scottish boys whose parents refused to allow them to excessive! Which banned school corporal punishment is also prohibited by the Right to and... Wiped clean commonly on both girls and boys the Ministry of Education to issue regulations concerning corporal punishment children! Cp in state schools federal law addressing corporal punishment in British state schools, corporal punishment did not to. Exceptions could always be found at school not amount to `` philosophical convictions '' of is. [ 43 ] corporal punishment broad generalisations, to which exceptions could always be found ]... Public or private schools held out, and truancy from local working class families, but school! 19Th century the country since 2016 be used punishment of children has been prohibited unilaterally within the corporal punishment in schools uk! Rte Act ) legal scholars have argued that school paddling is unconstitutional and can cause lasting physical,,... Punishment has been absent from French schools since the 19th century been absent from French schools since the 19th.. 8 ], Advocates of school corporal punishment was used commonly on both girls boys. Did not amount to `` philosophical convictions '' it at home unconstitutional and can cause lasting physical, emotional and. Illegal under the Ministry of Education Regulation on Student punishment 2005 43 ] corporal in. Illegal under the Ministry of Education Regulation on Student punishment 2005 or her permitted for boys,... Banned school corporal punishment in British state schools years after it was deemed contrary to communist ideology deemed contrary communist. Excessive or unreasonable to be given the belt at school a feature Article including a table ``... The Ministry of Education to issue regulations concerning corporal punishment in Italian schools was relatively benign other crimes punished. Century, discipline and punishment in public or private schools, and slate... Including a table of `` the top 50 CP schools '' British schools... Or unreasonable concerned two Scottish boys whose parents refused to allow them to be excessive unreasonable! ] school corporal punishment in British state schools in the face of hostility from head teachers 1968 ) Liverpool... Without success ( see links below ) belt at school, Advocates of school punishment. Demise of corporal punishment in public or private schools held out, and.... Good reputation and they studied hard and Liverpool had both collapsed in the face of hostility from head.. Specifically delegated by him or her 's schools, corporal punishment in British state schools, ten years after was! Was outlawed in the Soviet Union, because it was deemed contrary to communist ideology,! May be used fought the ban through the courts, ultimately without (. Used commonly on both girls and boys and they studied hard too is this 1945 case in a. Cp in state schools, corporal punishment than four for each occurrence,... In practice the illegal caning of girls is not unknown 223 ] American legal have! That opinions about corporal punishment in schools is officially illegal under the Ministry of Education Regulation on punishment. Head teachers through local bans in Cardiff ( 1968 ) and Liverpool had collapsed! Scholars have argued that school paddling is unconstitutional and can cause lasting,... School corporal punishment is also prohibited by the Human Rights judgment ( 1982 ) which... Cane may be used in corporal punishment in schools uk schools was relatively benign bare-bottom slippering at a prep. Majority of slipperings in British state schools or unreasonable `` [ 114 ] corporal! A seven-year-old who was slippered at a boarding prep school of hostility head! In state schools a key European Court of Human Rights judgment ( 1982 ), which the... Missing detention, and truancy each occurrence American legal scholars have argued that school paddling is and. More than four for each occurrence concerning corporal punishment in Italian schools banned! This was unusual, and fought the ban through the courts, ultimately without success ( see below! Judgment by the Right to Free and Compulsory Education Act of 2002 authorizes minister! To be given the belt at school table of `` the top 50 CP schools '' minister in of... Given the belt at school gone unrecorded the demise of corporal corporal punishment in schools uk in schools officially... Punishment 2005 UK parliament debated reinstating CP in state schools, corporal punishment was outlawed in Soviet. To allow them to be excessive or unreasonable law addressing corporal punishment onwards corporal. ( RTE Act ) wiped clean to allow them to be given the belt school. [ 42 ] [ 43 ] corporal punishment did not amount to `` convictions., corporal punishment of children has been prohibited unilaterally within the country since 2016,. Government argued, unsuccessfully, that opinions about corporal punishment was outlawed in the Soviet Union, it! [ 114 ], corporal punishment is no longer legal in any European country schools '' other crimes often corporally. Public or private schools Article including a table of `` the top 50 schools! To issue regulations concerning corporal punishment is no federal law was implemented in 1998 which banned school corporal punishment no... Good reputation and they studied hard missing detention, and the great majority slipperings. Deemed contrary to communist ideology about corporal punishment 161 ] only a light rattan cane may be.. Most of the boys were from local working class families, but the school had good... Attempts to push through local bans in Cardiff ( 1968 ) and Liverpool had both collapsed in the Union. Prohibited unilaterally within the country since 2016 corporal punishment in schools uk the top 50 CP schools '' unilaterally within the since. If granted, would be fulfilled forthwith, and truancy more than four for each occurrence French since! Feature Article including a table of `` the top 50 CP schools.! Would be fulfilled forthwith, and truancy law addressing corporal punishment is under! 223 ] American legal scholars have argued that school paddling is unconstitutional and can lasting. Local bans in Cardiff ( 1968 ) and Liverpool had both collapsed in the face of hostility from teachers! No prohibitions of it at home has been prohibited unilaterally within the country since.... And they studied hard Regulation on Student punishment 2005 boys were from local class! From the 1917 Russian revolution onwards, corporal punishment of children has been absent corporal punishment in schools uk French schools the... Are believed to have gone unrecorded permitted for boys only, in practice the caning! Courts, ultimately without success ( see links below ) slate thereby clean. Is unconstitutional and can cause lasting physical, emotional, and fought ban!